• Print
  • Send to a friend
  • Comment (5)
  •  

Lobster fishery to be delayed while price dispute continues

A DFO official holds a lobster in this 2010 file photo. Gary Kean

A DFO official holds a lobster in this 2010 file photo.

Cory Hurley
Published on April 14, 2012
Published on April 13, 2012
Cory Hurley  RSS Feed

Allan Sheppard started putting his lobster pots on his wharf Thursday in anticipation of the start of the season next week, but they may stay there for a while, according to the York Harbour fisherman.

Topics :
FFAW union , Newfoundland and Labrador , Boston , Bay of Islands , Nova Scotia

For close to 40 years, the south shore of the Bay of Islands man has experienced the literal and figurative ups and downs of the fishery. The latest blip on the radar for lobster fishermen is another price dispute with buyers.

This year, the FFAW union wants the weekly minimum price for the crustaceans tied to the Urner Barry index out of Boston, while the buyers are calling for the formula to be the weighted average daily price multiplied by 95 per cent.

The Seafood Processors of Newfoundland and Labrador Inc., which represents 25 processing facilities in this province, has said it can’t afford the price set by the Standing Fish Setting Price Panel. They are refusing to buy lobster.

It is consecutive years the two sides could not reach a deal, with a last-minute agreement allowing the season to go ahead as scheduled last year. It came following inquiries by the fishermen to sell their catch in other provinces.

Sheppard attended a meeting with FFAW representatives Friday morning, and said the union decided to delay next week’s season start by a week.

“We are not sure where we are going, none of the buyers are buying and the union are trying to get them back to the bargaining table to see what we are going to do,” he said.

The delayed start to the fishery will allow time for the union to look at outside buyers if things are not resolved with the local groups, according to Sheppard. Wednesday’s date to set traps for the Friday start has been moved to the following Wednesday.

There was a time the price was based on 70 per cent of the Boston market value. Although it was successful most times, Sheppard said, there were occasions fishermen did not get their fair share.

He said lobster was selling for $6.25 a pound in Nova Scotia last week, and typically it sells for approximately 75 cents less in this province. There has been a drop in the Nova Scotia prices since, so he would expect to be getting between $4.50 to $5 a pound to start the season.

Unfortunately, while that increase from recent years would be a positive, he said he is concerned buyers are refusing to pay it.

“If it works out, it would be good,” he said. “But, the buyers are saying they took a big loss from the lobster prices they paid last year. I don’t know if that is true or not.

“For years, we would get five and six dollars a pound for lobster, and it has only been the last couple of years, with the decline in the economy in the (United) States and the Canadian dollar (rising), we have not.”

Sheppard said he understands the market issues facing buyers, and said everybody is in a difficult situation. However, he said fishermen can’t participate in a fishery where they do not make a profit.

Right now, he is hoping for a resolve and to be able to get out on the water.

“We are optimistic,” he said. “Everybody was anxious to get started, and we thought we would get a decent price. Now, we don’t know where it will end up in a couple of weeks time when all of Nova Scotia comes on stream with their product.

“Our hands are tied. The union and the buyers will deal with it, the fishermen just have to hang tough and see what happens.”

churley@thewesternstar.com

Twitter: WS_CoryHurley

Comments

  • Username
    what is the customer paying for? a canadian fishermen? well I would be happy to pay less to a foreign fishermen.
    - May 3, 2012 at 20:50:49

    let's bring in cheaper foriegn workers and pay them less and then sell the lobster for less. lets cut our the canadian fishermen, let the companies make more money and pass some of the savings on to the consumer. The fish is to benefit the people.....well I argue that foriegn fishermen who get paid less will benefit the majority of citizens in NL by allowing the price of the product to be lower.....where is only a small minority gets a benefit from having canadian fishermen while the rest of us have to pay more to sustain their livlihood. I say we should cut out the canadian fishermen, and enjoy the savings.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Jack
    - April 14, 2012 at 16:56:04

    Time for Newfoundland and Labrador Government to allow fisherman to sell their catch outside the province, such as Nova Scotia or PEI where they can get a good price. If processors in Nova Scotia can afford to pay Lobster Fisherman fair market value, now is the for our counterparts to stop playing cheapskates and pay market prices.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Greg
    - April 14, 2012 at 15:49:21

    Stop with all this regulatory BS and let 'em sell it to whoever they want and however they want. The free market will set the price, that's the way it's supposed to be.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    John Hickey
    - April 14, 2012 at 10:19:31

    Although I sort of understand, and to a degree I sympathize with, the plight of Mr. Sheppard and his fellow fishermen, one must bear in mind that the demand has to be at least equal to the supply in order for things to work for everybody. As a consumer, I will not purchase lobster at a supermarket or seafood retailer when the price goes above $8.00 a pound. And, the only way it remains around or under that price is if those retailers are buying it from the fishermen under $5.00 a pound.. The real crux of the problem is that once the fishermen get a price that they can live with, they are happy, and they don't care what losses the retailers may incur should the demand be too low for them to sell what they've bought.. Consequently, the markets are very concerned about how much they can actually afford to invest into the buying of lobster based on calculated sales prospects and they're being predictably cautious.. There must be a meeting of the minds between the fishermen and the stores to arrive at a price that allows both sides to make a moderate profit yet still allow the consumer to buy at a reasonable price and avoid the necessity of gouging that consumer. Everyone who consumes lobster knows that more than 50% of the overall weight is discarded as inedible waste, so for every pound of lobster there's a half pound of edible meat. Looking at it that way, we, the consumers, are paying about 20 - 24 dollars a pound for the edible portion of our purchase...Ludicrous... So, time for the greedier ones to stop their whining and consider the customer. After all, without us paying the big bucks for your product, you don't sell it...Period...And, lobster is not a commodity that should be available to the filthy rich only.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Random Newf
    - April 14, 2012 at 08:12:40

    It is unreal when you think about it. Can't afford to give the fishermen a fair price, can't operate on the prices set by the panel, lol, what a joke. Seriously, the fishermen has to face hiking gas prices every spring, bait will average 30 to 40 cents per pound probably a little more, and yet the buyers can't afford to operate, well how in the hell do they expect the fishermen to operate. As for delaying the fishery for a week, that is very typical of the FFAW, lets delay it so these fishing people think we are actually trying to do something. I have been in a few unions in my day however this is one I can say accomplishes very little. I feel there are a couple things that can be done here: 1) Those refusing to pay the prices set by the panel, should lose their buyers rights. You don't want to pay, you lose the right to buy. 2) If the buyers in Newfoundland wish to set and rule their own pricing then not one single lobster ships off the island, not one. See how fast their horns are retracted then when they can't pay the workers $4 a pound take the lobsters out of their boats and ship them everywhere selling for approx $8 to $11 a pound. Delaying the fishery for a week will result in no difference, I really wish to be proven wrong however from following the news and judging from past FFAW battles, they just go through the motions making the people paying their union dues every year think I am part of a Union. Thats my 5cents on the matter whether its woth 5 or not.

    Submit a comment

Submit a comment

Submit a comment (we keep all emails private)
Agreement

We ask that users remain courteous. You may not post insulting, discriminatory or inappropriate content, which may be removed at our discretion. We are not responsible for user content and opinions. Use of this site as well as content submission & ownership are governed by our Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy.

Member organizations should be non-profit in nature, and promote legal activities. Any organization found promoting illegal activities or commercial products or services will be deleted from the site.

I agree with these conditions.

Advertising

Business Directory


Milestones Moving Up

Newsletter

Please enter your email to receive our free newsletter

Subscribe to news alerts

Advertising