• Print
  • Send to a friend
  • Comment (28)
  •  

** Updated **Mill workers reject pension plan funding relief measures

This is the press release issued by Kruger this morning.

This is the press release issued by Kruger this morning.

Published on May 18, 2012
Published on May 18, 2012
Lorrayne Anthony  RSS Feed

Unionized workers at Corner Brook Pulp and Paper have rejected a proposal by Kruger to make changes to their pension plan.

Topics :
Kruger Inc.

Out  of 326 active union employees, 177 objected to giving the company an extra five years to fund the unfunded portion of the pension plan. The rejections amount to 54.3 per cent.

Thirty-one of the 617 retired union members voted against the proposal.

The vote results for the non-union plan showed only six objections among active employees and seven from retirees.

Kruger Inc. says it will be reassessing the viability of the mill's operations.

  

Here is the text of the release:

KRUGER TO REASSESS THE VIABILITY OF ITS CORNER BROOK OPERATION

Pension plan funding relief measures rejected by active unionized employees

Corner Brook, NL, May 18, 2012 – Kruger Inc. today announced that it will reassess the viability of Corner Brook Pulp and Paper’s operations after one of four groups of pension plan members rejected the proposal to apply funding relief measures to its pension plan deficits.

Today, independent auditor Brian N. Hillier issued his final report showing the total number of objections received before the May 17 deadline from each group, as follows:

 

-Pension Plan for Unionized Employees:

>Active members (326): 177 objections 54.3%

>Retired members (617): 31 objections 5.0%

 

-Pension Plan for Non-Unionized Employees:

>Active members (78): 6 objections 7.7%

>Retired members (218): 7 objections 3.2%

 

Under NL legislation, in order for the relief measures to be applied, they cannot be

opposed by more than one-third of members in each group (active and retirees).

Consequently, with 54.3% of active unionized employees opposing the proposal,

the relief measures cannot be applied to the unionized employees’ pension plan.

 

The relief measures were a crucial element in the Mill’s strategy to improve its

competitiveness and secure its future. In recent years, the Kruger Company has

gone to extraordinary lengths to support its Corner Brook operation in a very

challenging market afflicted by declining demand for newsprint, increasing energy

costs and the negative effects of a strong Canadian currency on exports.

In addition to these challenges, the Corner Brook Mill has to contend with other

Canadian paper mills that have competitive operating costs and benefit from the

additional advantage of funding relief measures for their own pension plan deficits.

 

The Company is disappointed with this outcome, especially considering the

countless efforts that were put in over the last few weeks to communicate with

plan members to seek their support.

 

Founded in 1904, Kruger Inc. is a major producer of publication papers, tissue,

lumber and other wood products, corrugated cartons from recycled fibres, green and

renewable energy and wines and spirits. The Company is also a leader in paper and

paperboard recycling in North America. Kruger operates facilities in Quebec, Ontario,

British Columbia, Newfoundland and Labrador and the United States.

Comments

  • Username
    Long Gone
    - May 22, 2012 at 12:26:55

    The general public has no idea what goes on in CBPP. I am still owed part of my pension, and cannot get it until the 5 Yrs pass, same time as Mr. Kruger has to pay the fund. For years, I payed my share to the pension fund share every week. What did Mr. Kruger pay, $0. He used our pension to play the markets not only to pay the pension fund, but because Kruger Inc didn't have to shell out millions, the money that was saved was used to build Joe's empire. I am betting the equity in the mill is the key to the empire. Once the mill goes, so does the empire. Why else would someone keep pouring money in? As to the crew who like to bash the workers, lets keep some money in NL, why send it to Montreal? You can be sure of one thing, If Kruger says "do this, or we may have to do something" THE DECISION HAS ALREADY BEEN MADE TO DO IT ANYWAYS, even if you do what they want.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Ms. Mill worker
    - May 21, 2012 at 13:12:33

    Ms Morgan. The union bosses as you like to put it (why stop there why not call them mobsters.....) are not paid. They volunteer their time to protect this city, province and it's workers from being treated like 3rd class citizens....... After they work their own 50 hr work week. Please do your research prior to making such slanderous accusations and Posting your real name........ Brilliant. You stick to typing and cooking. We'll look after the paper.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Shawn
    - May 21, 2012 at 10:37:47

    You people just can't see the forest for the trees! The writing has been on the wall for this mill for many years now. Every couple of years a little of the mill and it's workforce is put down and this mill is doomed to die anyway. This operation has been held over the people of Corner Brook head's for far too long. All the company was truly looking to do with these "relief" measures is make a few more dollars as best they could before they closed this mill anyway. The end of that mill will come soon reguardless of todays squable over the pension fund. It was time to make this stand and let the chips fall where they may. It's time for Corner Brook to mature away from it's childhood and step out on its own, without the mill, for better or worse. It may well do Corner Brook good to be knocked down a notch anyways, and possibly lose some of the highly inflated costs of living around here.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    A true newfie
    - May 21, 2012 at 08:20:20

    Wow....... This city really is dead....... On the inside. I can't believe everyone is making such uninformed comments. It Is easy to tell who is working behind a Desk 8-4 Monday to Friday with ANy sick days, with an insurance Plan whereby the employer interferes in medical benefits (he is after all the major stockholder). I wonder did any of you spend 40,000.00 on an education only to be lied to about our future? That's right OUR future. Everyone is sooooo concerned with the mills Future And the citys future........ Well what about MY future? I have to break my back and my wallet to subsidize Canadas 30th most wealthy person? Come on man, try to swallow your OwN greed And jealousy. I don't hang My head when I pick Up my pay stub....... In fact, the thought in my head on Wednesdays is "Joe Is lucky to have me. Don't fool yourself. The unions are Smarter and stronger than ever. To the pensioners Wife- packing his basket and washing his socks doesn't really justify your opinion.......ask one of the girls employed there. None of you have any grounds To spew your assumptions. Why not show the rest Of the province we are not the dumb rednecks who are their own worst enemies....... Because trust me.... Thats the general consensus of This pseudo city. Smarten up, read as know The facts before you Start slinging dirt at The people who would be the heartbeat of this city....... If it even had a heart. Well done Corner Brook lets bay her up Some more........... Idiots. - here an appropriate example of the use of his Pronoun.

    Submit a comment

    • Username
      a business man
      - May 23, 2012 at 10:32:44

      I don't know who you are "A TRUE NEWFIE" so I honestly am not concerned with your future. I pay much more in taxes than most make annually, and as such, I am upset that my tax dollars are being used to subsidize this mill. As a result, I want to see the mill close worn. I went to school, and I work behind a desk. I look at factory jobs like the ones at the mill, and I shudder at the thought of my children and grandchildren having to do such menial work. If you ask me, all Canadians are too good for this type of work. We should move away from this know of work and move towards jobs in innovation, technology, medical research and so on. SO, on that note, I beleive that the closure of the mill is actually a step in the right direction. So lets turn on the bulldozer, and erase a now useless part of our past and tear the mill down.

    • Username
      A TRUE NEWFIE
      - May 25, 2012 at 20:35:51

      Business Man (supposedly) - how many more times do you have to be told that your silly little tax dollars do not subsidize Kruger for electricity. Please pick another stance, this one is getting old and you are absolutely wrong on it. KRUGER MAKES ELECTRICITY KELSO!!! Thats why theres a big green K up on the Deer Lake Power building. My God by' are you retarded? READ THE RESPONSES TO YOUR COMMENTS IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO KNOW SOME OF THE FACTS ( I typed in all caps because I'm not real sure you know how to make the small letters yet)........ Are you by any chance the dude on McWhirters Lane with all the cats? If you are then I'm sorry man for all the meanness due to your issues....... if not then man you really need a vacation...... from neptune.

  • Username
    Steve
    - May 18, 2012 at 23:36:52

    lol, seeing all these dimwits spouting off like they know what their talking about is funny as all heck. please keep spouting off.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Smrtrthnu
    - May 18, 2012 at 23:25:08

    Alright now geniuses.....you reject the mills proposal...so what kind of pedestal do you think you have been put on??? Have you not thought of the repercussions of your actions? Have you not even considered the hundreds of people who are going to be directly affected by your lack of judgement? If that mill closes, that guilt shall forever weigh on the shoulders of those who obviously are not looking into their future. You all lose....how the hell will you sleep at night with your insane decision.....congrats on ruining the lives of young families...As well as your own...

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    David
    - May 18, 2012 at 22:41:28

    You aren't good employees...you 're incredible unemployees.

    Submit a comment

    • Username
      Bob marley
      - May 21, 2012 at 08:32:51

      Have pity on those whose chances grow thinner...... You sir are an incredible example of all those bayman townies talk about. You'll never be civilized because you fight each other instead of helping. Bottom line is mill shuts, no one cares except YOU people...... Why are you so ignorant to your hometown? These unions have been putting bread on YOUR table since you've been born. You said it yourself, the mill is dead. You think it won't affect you? Then you are even more silly than your comments prove. Don't expect professional and intelligent people to sell the farm to save the pigsty. This mill isn't he be all end all for these workers...... They're just waiting for severance Pay so they can move on with their lives and stop worrying about saving a city that doesn't deserve it anyway. If labour is Cheap in the rest of the industry (which it's Not) then that's grand. Let's see Joe get access to all the virgin fibre from the spruce and fir (the best for newsprint). Oh that's right, he can't. That's why he came here in the first place. The timber. So please. Get your ducks In a row before you want to Personally attack people who already know what they are talking about. Go back to your taxi stand by'

    • Username
      a business man
      - May 23, 2012 at 11:38:31

      Hey bob marley, I do not care if the mill shuts down. I want it to shut down. I feel bad for the people who will be displaced but I want the mill to shut down do that my tax dollars will never subsidize it again, and I want the mill to shut down because I actually have a financial interest that will increase in value upon the closure of the mill. The reality is that while the timber used to produce the newsprint may be important, the workers surely are not. The workers are just tools to be replaced when a cheaper better tool comes along. In this day and age of free trade, the timber can be exported to another country and the product can be produced there. There is not reason as to why this mill HAS to be in cornerbrook. Unions have never put anything on my table, but I will say that I have made quite a living though my offshoring/outsourcing companies by targeting jobs done by unionized workers. It is simple math really....it is quite easy to undercut a worker who believes he should get more and more and more until the end of time. All I have to do if find a cheaper way for the employer to get things done, and I get to put some of the money saving by outsourcing/offshoring into my own pocket.

    • Username
      David
      - May 23, 2012 at 17:25:53

      Bob: What good would pity do? Help these people remain oblivious to reality as they send their own jobs away to Quebec or New Brunswick? Is that your 'preferred behavior'? Is that in any way helpful, or is calling a spade a spade so that someone, somday might use their brain for themsleves a positive step? You are as big a loser as these other eejots.

  • Username
    a business man
    - May 18, 2012 at 21:08:01

    Well, if the workers do not accept the conditions that are deemed necessary by the company, then the company should move and find workers that will. there is nothing at all that these workers can do that workers from another country can do. Then factor in the high canadian dollar.....likely, people from anywhere else in the world can do the same work that these workers do for less. There is no reason for the company to stay in Canada. Even if the workers accepted the proposal. the company should close the doors and bulldoze the plant so that NL can move forward. I would welcome a Walmart or a Dollar Store. We don't need a pulp and paper plant anymore.....we can get the same products from offshore suppliers at a cheaper cost.

    Submit a comment

    • Username
      Bob marley
      - May 21, 2012 at 08:45:30

      Wow you must be a really successful business owner if that's your suggestion. One minor question for the experts though......... If he pulls this paper mill out of CB Where is it again he will have access to an abundant as well as the best fibre With which to make the newsprint? Just wondering........ also - I know A couple of CEO's who are also really bad at Making business decisions. Maybe you could hire Them at your bake sale? Though they'd Have a bit of difficulty I'm pretty sure They can be trained to your liking........ Sad

    • Username
      a business man
      - May 23, 2012 at 11:31:51

      The "best fibre" can be transported to any are in the world to make the newsprint. The reality is that the fibre IS what is important to the production of newsprint, whereas the workers are just unskilled uneducated workers who can be easily replaced at a cheaper cost in a different country. It seems logical for this company to shut down and re-open somewhere else. The can import the fibre from NL and produce elsewhere.

  • Username
    TK
    - May 18, 2012 at 20:41:43

    Contrary to some of the above comments, I've heard that the company were forcing union employees to do work outside the CBA, thereby creating mistrust. If that is indeed the case, maybe the company was doing these things to force the union to vote the way it did and therefore shift the blame for the closing of the mill.

    Submit a comment

    • Username
      Bob Marley
      - May 24, 2012 at 12:08:06

      O.m.g....... Keep talking kiddies ur proving my point....... Bus nines- how cheap do you think the shipping industry is today? Right, higher than ever. So You suggest cheaper labour but spend more $$$$ in shipping? That's what you call biting off your nose to spite your face. So let's spend money shipping the wood, on an open wood barge all the way around the world, hopefully, but doubtebly makes it to Asia. You make the paper for half the labour cost and then ship it back halfway around the world? Awesome job Einstein......... Ask ANY shipping company that cost. It costs 120000/ day just to be at a Port.............. Againdo you want fries With that order of fodder? Outsourcing works for Some companies but not this one. As far as your tax dollars Subsidising the mill, u might want to get after the PC government on that. They're the idiots Funnelling money into corner brook So He can spend on Quebec mills....... If u were a Real business man you'd know these Obvious and available FACTS Dumb Dave- the pity I was Referring to in one of The best known songs EVeR was referriń to you! Not the workers. "let them all pass all their dirty remarks, there is One question I'd really love to ask Is there a place for the hopeless Sinner who has hurt all mankind just to save his own? Believe me. Let's get together to fight this holy armegedon, so when the end comes, there will be no doom. HAVE PITY ON THoSE WHOSE CHANCES GROW THINNER, there ain't no hiding place from the father of creation. One love, one heart let's get together and feel alright....... I guess you think it's Alright to abuse other nations to benefit your own....... To ahead and dispute Bob and call him an idiot..... Your karma is Screwed now Anyway........... "observe the hypocrits, who mingle with the good People we meet" . Get a conscience By.......... Or are ya happy Africa is Starving too? Yes by, me...... Ask you for pity? You MUST be nuts.

  • Username
    george p b
    - May 18, 2012 at 20:21:14

    Keep in mind that the pension fund is Kruger's obligation. Kruger owes the workers their pensions per labor law. Like many other companies Kruger raided their pensions funds, because politicians let them.... Now if Kruger pulls up stakes, they will be responsible for making the mill site environmentally clean. Do not let the government officials permit Kruger to slip away quietly in the night....

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Foghorn Leghorn
    - May 18, 2012 at 19:10:45

    A friend of mine had a saying - You can't fix stupid!

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    johnnyray
    - May 18, 2012 at 18:14:13

    Hate to say I told you so. Corner Brook will survive it just wont be with the mill. Dont blame the company on this one, blame the greedy union for not budging. Sorry but you got noone to blame but yourself.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    pensioner's wife
    - May 18, 2012 at 17:19:00

    It is unreasonable that fewer than 18% of the persons permitted to vote can make a decision that will have such a possibly negative affect on the remaining 82+%. Unbelievable!

    Submit a comment

    • Username
      a business man
      - May 18, 2012 at 21:03:32

      normally I would post a comment that is supportive of your logic, but the closure of the mill serves my interests and the vote today is a step towards the closure of the mill. therefore, I will state that these are the rules that govern this unionized workplace, so the results are valid even if the make the mill's closure more likely.

  • Username
    Talking Smoke
    - May 18, 2012 at 15:00:28

    Goodbye Corner Brook Paper Mill and the people of Corner Brook can thank the unionized members. Don't blame Kruger.... Make room for a bunch of Dollar Stores........

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Dave from NL
    - May 18, 2012 at 14:19:58

    Way to go boys......don't look past your nose. Lets show everyone that you are just as smart as the mill workers in Stephenville and Grand Falls.Opps! My mistake; there are NO mill workers in Stephenville or Grand Falls.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    William Wallace
    - May 18, 2012 at 13:59:12

    Stupid move much? Let's do some maths shall we.... half of nuttin is nuttin. Unbelievable that the unionized workers would make such a stupid move.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Jack
    - May 18, 2012 at 12:22:02

    After the Abitibi-Bowater, now known as Resolute Forest Products, employees at the Stephenville and Grand Falls-Windsor mills rejected their concessions and resulting in mill closures, I thought that Corner Brook Pulp and Paper unionized employees would know better, but they didn't. Because unionized Corner Brook Pulp and Paper employees rejected the proposal, it appears to me that they didn't learn from mistakes without thinking about the negative consequences their decision will have on every single Newfoundlander and Labradorian outside the Avalon. These consequences include substantially higher property and business taxes for Corner Brookers to make up the revenue shortfall resulting from the mill closure, service cuts for Corner Brook, Newfoundland and Labrador's Forestry sector is destroyed, mass exodus to Western Canada including Alberta, Western Newfoundland will lose their largest manufacturing employer, Corner Brook will lose out to more competitive and business friend Humber Valley area communities like Pasadena and Deer Lake, and Corner Brook could be stripped of its "city" status due to declining population levels relating to the mill closure. At the end of the day, while I might take the heat for this statement, I have to speak the truth. I hope unionized Corner Brook Pulp and Paper employees are happy, they not only ruined the city and make lives unaffordable for Corner Brookers, but they also ruined Western Newfoundland.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    David
    - May 18, 2012 at 11:52:57

    Shrwwd move, Ferguson.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Joan Marie Morgan
    - May 18, 2012 at 11:39:09

    Unions going to shut down another business in this province. Fish plants, paper mills, doesn't matter to union brass as long as they get their big pay cheques. Well good thing is they won't be able to cut brush for a few weeks every year and collect EI. so now maybe the union members will have some back bone and stand up to the thugs who run the show. Guys for God's sake the union bosses always get looked after they won't be off to Alberta in the fall looking for work. Wake up and take your lives back.

    Submit a comment

Submit a comment

Submit a comment (we keep all emails private)
Agreement

We ask that users remain courteous. You may not post insulting, discriminatory or inappropriate content, which may be removed at our discretion. We are not responsible for user content and opinions. Use of this site as well as content submission & ownership are governed by our Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy.

Member organizations should be non-profit in nature, and promote legal activities. Any organization found promoting illegal activities or commercial products or services will be deleted from the site.

I agree with these conditions.

Advertising

Business Directory


Milestones Moving Up

Newsletter

Please enter your email to receive our free newsletter

Subscribe to news alerts

Advertising