• Print
  • Send to a friend
  • Comment (13)
  •  

Griffin appeals city council’s rejection of development

Gary Kean
Published on February 26, 2013
Published on February 25, 2013
Gary Kean  RSS Feed

CORNER BROOK  Businessman Danieal Griffin, who had his plans to start a modular home construction facility spurned several times by Corner Brook’s city council, is appealing his latest rejection.

Topics :
Johnson Construction , Western Star

The city turned down Griffin’s fourth version of his plan for the project on the Massey Drive access road on the city’s western outskirts during council’s Feb. 11 public meeting.

Griffin’s three previous attempts to convince the city to permit the development on Crown land he would purchase from the provincial government were rejected in late 2011.

On Monday, Griffin filed an appeal of council’s decision with the appeals board, which functions at arm’s length from the city itself. He said the rejection of the project was “based on personal opinions” and not by the requirements laid out by the city’s application process or regulations.

At the public meeting earlier this month, Coun. Leo Bruce expressed his concerns about Griffin’s proposal, calling it “an idea, and that’s all it is,” and that he would approve it if he thought it would be a success. Bruce also expressed concern about the land potentially going undeveloped while other parcels of land around it were developed, and how such a situation might force the city to buy the property back from Griffin several years down the road.

Not only did the city say Griffin cannot develop that land because it is beyond the current reach of municipal water and sewer services, council also put a moratorium on any further development in the area until services can be extended there.

“I just want the public to know what I put in there,” Griffin told The Western Star on Monday. “It’s not just some random plan to go in there and steal all this land.”

Griffin said he has never failed at any of his previous business ventures and worked out the financial planning for this one before any other aspect.

In the document he filed with the appeals board, Griffin said he is actually not required to provide a full financial synopsis or detailed business plan. The only mention of finances on the application, he said, is the estimated construction value.

“If anything, I have provided more in terms of financial details than was ever required, as well as benefits to the city,” said Griffin.

According to Griffin, his project could create as many as 100 jobs and might add as much as $250,000 to the municipality’s tax base.

As for the land not being serviced, Griffin said his plans included a pump station to provide water, a fire suppression system and environmentally friendly, composting toilets. His latest plan also contains a 35-metre buffer zone from water bodies, where he is only required to have a 15-metre one, and has decreased the overall environmental footprint of the project’s size.

The pump system would be similar to the one installed by Johnson Construction, a company that has already been allowed to develop a parcel of land adjacent to where Griffin wants to develop his facility.

“I feel the moratorium on development in that area ... until services are installed to that area is completely unnecessary as it is only hindering development,” said Griffin in the appeal document.

The city had urged Griffin to set up his plant on Lundrigan Drive, although the city also told him that plan would require him to spend more than $1 million to fix up an access road to the land the city would sell to him for nearly $30,000.

“Clearly, they had no qualms about risks in getting the land back (if the venture failed) when approving my Lundrigan Drive proposal,” said Griffin.

Council’s decision, said Griffin, does not show the city is interested in attracting new business and land development. He wants the city to reverse its decisions on both the rejection of his plan and the moratorium on development.

“This does not show a municipal desire to attract business,” said Griffin. “If anything, it will act as a deterrent for any other businesses who want to set up shop.”

 

gkean@thewesternstar.com

Twitter: WS_GaryKean

Comments

  • Username
    mainlander
    - February 27, 2013 at 01:11:54

    If this guy is serious about his business proposal just show the council your business plan and approved financing no big deal unless he dont have either and by the sounds of it he dont have either.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Corner Brook Tax Payer
    - February 26, 2013 at 13:59:12

    Mr. Griffin, why are you insisting on setting up your business in Corner Brook? Given the problems you have had with the City and the council, why not set up your business in Stephenville or Deer Lake? As a business person you must consider the lost revenue you have incurred over the past couple of dealing with the City and cut your losses....move on.

    Submit a comment

    • Username
      Jack
      - February 26, 2013 at 18:18:22

      Corner Brook Tax Payer, its obvious you don't want job creation in this city. Its people like you whom are the root of the city's economic problems.

    • Username
      Shawn
      - February 27, 2013 at 09:11:36

      Most likely it's because he feels that most of his sales will come from the Corner Brook local area. There are far more housing starts in this area than Pasadena and Stephenville. Transport of modular homes is a big deal and an added expense to the selling price and the business bottom line. I though that would be obvious to anyone actually paying attention.

  • Username
    Jack
    - February 26, 2013 at 12:03:13

    If you're wondering why I'm comparing Neville Greeley and Leo Bruce to the former Nova Scotian Premier, Rodney MacDonald, here is my explanation. Prior to October 4, 2006, Nova Scotia was Canada's only province to have a ban on Sunday Shopping for all department stores except pharmacies, book stores, gas stations, video rental outlets, or any small sized store. These restrictions were based on store size. In mid 2006, Sobey's and Loblaw's, Atlantic Superstore parent company, found a loophole in Nova Scotia's Sunday Shopping laws, and they subdivided their supermarkets into smaller stores to keep their supermarkets open on Sunday. On June 23, 2006, the MacDonald Government banned supermarkets and department stores from subdividing their outlets into separate units. The breaking point came on July 2, 2006, when Halifax Regional Police entered the Barrington Street Atlantic Superstore location armed with measuring tapes and investigating this store to see if Loblaw's are breaking Nova Scotia's Sunday Shopping law. This battle will be known as the "Sunday Shopping War". Fed up with the regulatory abuse, Sobey's and Loblaw's took the next step, they took the Nova Scotia Government to court. October 4, 2006 was the day Sunday Shopping bans were history in Nova Scotia as the courts ruled that the MacDonald Government overstepped their regulatory authority. In response to the court's ruling, Rodney MacDonald made a decision to lift the Sunday Shopping ban in Nova Scotia for good. The lessons learned from Nova Scotia's "Sunday Shopping War" of 2006 is that when provincial or municipal governments abuse regulations or use every excuse possible to reject great ideas, you suffer the consequences. In other words, since Neville Greeley and Leo Bruce are not learning from Rodney MacDonald's mistakes, they will be next to suffer.

    Submit a comment

    • Username
      Sorry Jack
      - February 26, 2013 at 18:20:53

      Jack, Can you use another example? Perhaps compare Greeley to some foreign dictator that people in NL know, as opposed to Rodney whatshisface?As for Sobeys- you forget how they come across that loophole. As a person who was in that area when all this was going on, were it not for Pete's Frootique (a store I shopped at on Sundays before this nonsense started), that loophole would not have been exploited. Pete's was able to be open because it was a small 'produce market' that sold canned goods and meat. Pete's Frootique were told they had to divide their store (which they had been set up to do by pulling a rope across- the front half is still only produce). Canadian Tire joined in because service stations were able to be open, so they opened their service stations with a rope across the service area entrance to the actual store. Loblaws and Sobeys decided to divide their store to allow people to buy produce, just like Pete's. This all occurred after a vote which the slim majority voted for the status quo- no Sunday shopping. The people of NS democratically decided they did not want to shop on Sundays. The ratio was not as slim as the vote to enter NL into confederation. It really came down to whether the Government was willing to tell Pete that he had to close his entire store down on Sundays (ticking off all of downtown Halifax in the process)- but that loophole based on size could not be changed easily, so Pete could not be closed. Add to that a huge uproar from 'hardly voted' Cape Breton and their tourism biz, and they lifted the ban. http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/story/2006/06/23/nova-scotia-shopping.html

  • Username
    Rod Mercer
    - February 26, 2013 at 11:28:43

    What about the two promising phone calls Griffin allegedly received from Stephenville and Pasadena? I'm sure the consultant that he has been working with for more then a year would consider Pasadena to have the visibility and highway access that he requires. Griffin appears to want the Corner Brook stream and no other place. In my mind, it smells of land speculation and not a legitimate business proposal. Where are all those other municipalities that were courting you Mr. Griffin? It appears the honeymoon was very brief.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Mrs. Clause
    - February 26, 2013 at 10:25:53

    I'll be some happy to see the back of this joke of a Council. Keep up the fight Danny!

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Ernie Anbert
    - February 26, 2013 at 09:05:03

    Corner Brook is the most backward town (yes town) I have ever encountered. It seems your council is made up of a bunch of low rate know it all's. Who would rather see the area cater to their own needs than the needs of the people. Just wondering if they will consider growth when Kruger drops everything and leaves everything for the city to deal with. It's going to happen, so why not start development NOW while u still have a few people livig here?

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Danieal Griffin
    - February 26, 2013 at 08:28:17

    Specific to the allegation that I haven’t changed my proposal by one specific councillor, Coun. Gary Kelly, I would like to point out that I changed my application drawings to ensure his concerns about the buffer zone were addressed. As stated in the above article.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Jack
    - February 26, 2013 at 07:58:57

    Neville Greeley and Leo Bruce, Corner Brook's version of former Nova Scotian Premier, Rodney MacDonald as they have a reputation for abusing government regulations for their personal gain.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    CBRes
    - February 26, 2013 at 07:38:53

    So any business wanting to set up shop in Corner Brook, has to submit financial statements? Did Joe Tippett of HTH Investments submit the same when he applied for the development permits to (purchase land) build on Broadway ? Sounds like more of the double standards and loose interpretation of rules that do not exist.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Jackie Barrett
    - February 26, 2013 at 07:35:07

    With Corner Brook City Council, particularly Leo Bruce, proving to Corner Brookers time and time again that they're anti-entrepreneur, I'm glad the Daniel Griffin is putting his foot down and decided to launch an appeal with their Appellate board. Even better, he should go the path of Trent Quinton, John's Point Subdivision developer whom was stopped from Corner Brook City Council, and take this matter to the Provincial and Appellate courts. Referring to "The Western Star" news story, "City concedes negligence in issuing permit". Daniel Griffin also gave an excellent quote stating "If anything, it will act as a deterrent for any other businesses who want to set up shop" as he nailed it right on the button. In light of Corner Brook City Council's recent string of business rejections due to their regulatory abuse including the Trent Quinton's "John's Point Subdivision" which is now before the courts, Deejay Penney's "Teen Dance Hall", Daniel Griffin's "Modular Home Plant", and the great Costco Wholesale rejection due to a foolish and unprovable excuse, Daniel Griffin clearly has proof that Corner Brook City Hall's rejection of great business ideas prove that City Council's ignorance will hurt this city's ability to grow. In my opinion, Neville Greeley and Leo Bruce are now turning into Newfoundland and Labrador's version of former Nova Scotian Premier, Rodney MacDonald, whom had a reputation for abusing government regulations that backfired against him in the end, including the Sunday Shopping wars with Sobey's and Loblaw's in 2006. If Corner Brook allowed residents from outside the city to run for Mayor or City Council, I will definitely run for Mayor, and if elected, the first step is to make Corner Brook Canada's best place to do business with or without the council's blessing, not the worse like it is now.

    Submit a comment

Submit a comment

Submit a comment (we keep all emails private)
Agreement

We ask that users remain courteous. You may not post insulting, discriminatory or inappropriate content, which may be removed at our discretion. We are not responsible for user content and opinions. Use of this site as well as content submission & ownership are governed by our Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy.

Member organizations should be non-profit in nature, and promote legal activities. Any organization found promoting illegal activities or commercial products or services will be deleted from the site.

I agree with these conditions.

Advertising

Business Directory


Milestones Moving Up

Newsletter

Please enter your email to receive our free newsletter

Subscribe to news alerts

Advertising