• Print
  • Send to a friend
  • Comment (10)
  •  

Property problems

Walter Porter is not at all happy with the state the lawn and lower driveway of his Lomond Street property were left in by the City of Corner Brook’s snowclearing operations this past winter.   Gary Kean

Walter Porter is not at all happy with the state the lawn and lower driveway of his Lomond Street property were left in by the City of Corner Brook’s snowclearing operations this past winter.

Gary Kean
Published on March 13, 2013
Published on March 12, 2013
Gary Kean  RSS Feed

Resident says city should be doing more to compensate residents for damage caused by snowclearing

CORNER BROOK  Walter Porter has had damage done to his property by snow clearing operations before, but now he’s had enough of it.

Topics :
Corner Brook , Lomond Street

The retired schoolteacher, now in his 80s, had a contractor come in last summer to makeover his front lawn and to pave the second driveway on his property on the sharp, hilly turn on Lomond Street.

He was mad enough when the snowplow operator kept dumping snow into his often unoccupied lower driveway, rendering it unusable for him. He was even more irate when the snow began to melt and revealed his front lawn has been torn up by the snowplow blade.

There are tire marks trenched into the front of his lawn above the curbside, and sod and dirt atop the nearly melted snowbank. His lower driveway is still not only filled with snow, but more sod and dirt that has been scoured off his newly repaired lawn.

“They have to come and repair this, but I want compensation too,” said Porter. “I’m considering talking to my lawyer and taking court action if I am not satisfied.”

Porter said the City of Corner Brook should be doing more to prevent this type of property damage from recurring on the same properties every year.

“There should be more communication between the managers and the people driving these snowplows and snowblowers,” he said, adding that the city should be removing snow from areas where efficient snowclearing operations are a challenge.

“They should be using trucks to remove the snow and dump it in the harbour or something like that.”

See REPAIRED on page 2

The City of Corner Brook repaired 190 lawns damaged by snowclearing operations last year. The claims don’t usually start coming in until later in spring, but there are 30 such requests filed with the city so far this year.

The city allocates $20,000 for property damage claims and usually works within that budget.

Porter said he has called the city about his concerns, but has not yet filed a claim.

“I want someone to come and talk to me about this first and to take a look at what they did to my lawn,” he said.

Rayna Luther, the City of Corner Brook’s assistant director of operational services, said it is not the city’s policy to meet with property owners who file claims.

“We add them all to a list and then, when the contract is awarded, those addresses get passed on to the contractor and we follow up that way,” said Luther, noting that the tender for that contract will be advertised this coming weekend.

According to the city’s website, claims are reviewed and property owners are notified by mail of the city’s decision regarding whether the property will be repaired.

It’s difficult to prevent damage in some areas, but Luther said there are ways to help snowclearing equipment operators know where lawns are beneath the snowbanks.

“People on corner lots are trickier and there are some cases where we get repeat ones,” she commented. “We do allow people to put up wooden markers and the operators do their best to work around them. Sometimes they get knocked down, unfortunately, but in some cases they do help minimize the damage.”

Given the number of lawns in Corner Brook, the amount of snow the area gets in an average winter and the frequency of snowclearing operations, Luther said 190 repair jobs last season is typical and not an unreasonable number.

As for using equipment smaller than the big loaders on troublesome avenues, Luther believes Lomond Street is big enough for the larger heavy equipment.

“On the smaller streets, we do use smaller equipment like backhoes with blades on them, but the loaders are sufficient for roads the size of Lomond Street,” she said.

Any resident who would like to register their property with the lawn repair list can call the city’s customer service line at 637-1666.

gkean@thewesternstar.com

Twitter: WS_GaryKean

Comments

  • Username
    Henry says
    - March 13, 2013 at 20:04:21

    Sorry to hear of your lawn damage. The city damaged my lawn in the same manner a number of times during the winter snow clearing. They sent the hydro. seed guy and did a patch up. I requested two sods to repair and they stated that current. Policy was hydro seed only. The hydro seed did not grow in the damage and weeds developed. I will never let the city come near my property again. The city does not operate with good intentions and they are not interested in. Making up for the damage. My opinion the city needs to. Be challenged when it comes to damage to our properties. I often. Wondered what would happen if I damaged city lawns or trees. I guess they would. Use city. Resources and take me to court and spend what ever it takes. I guess when. It comes to the citizens its " Let them. eat cake". Let's get them at the ballot box.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Newf E
    - March 13, 2013 at 15:51:44

    The City doesn't fix the lawns either. We have lawns in our area that have been damaged for years on end. The contractor they hire does a pathetic job. I have watched them do my lawn last year. They use hydra-seed mixed with very large rocks. Rocks the larger then eggs. They did more damage "fixing" my lawn then the plow did. They drove by one day, threw dirt in the damaged area. Then another day hydra-seed. The entire process took less then 5 mins. That's how much time they spent on it. My damaged area was 60feet long by foot wide. The city is hopeless. Worse city I have ever lived in when it comes to these things. Worse "services" I have ever seen. The dirtiest least cared for town with property taxes so high it makes no sense.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    is this his property or public right of way
    - March 13, 2013 at 13:21:22

    i have empathy for this senior citizen; life long taxpayer in cbrook; but where does his property line end; and public right of way begin; i doubt he owes the land right to side of paved road; looks in this pic that the tire track is not really on his lawn but actually right of way; public property belonging to city cornerbrook and its taxpayers; for public use...walking; bike riding; parking etc; etc; and for certain the last 10/15 feet of his driveway; intersects roadway Lomond st. which is definitely city property....his land should be fixed up a bit...but he shouldnt expect loader not to clear snow from the roadway; especially after the winter we had this year...

    Submit a comment

    • Username
      Carla Parsons
      - March 13, 2013 at 21:29:37

      You should go and take a look before you comment on where the damage to his property is located , because it is on his property not the cities, and he pays very high property taxes each year and should be compensated for the damage !

  • Username
    Tom
    - March 13, 2013 at 13:09:27

    Simple solution...put up markers! How the heck can these operators tell where the road and lawn meet up under all the snow. It's not rocket science!

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Jim Jim
    - March 13, 2013 at 11:58:13

    Where are your snow markers that clearly mark your land? If this is a regular routine, why wouldn't you put up markers to help the process? If this were a real City the City would say... you don't have markers up.... not our problem. Perhaps a real City would hire plow operators with xray vision to see through the snow banks.

    Submit a comment

    • Username
      Devil's Advocate
      - March 14, 2013 at 10:51:23

      Real cities do not have operators with x-ray vision, nor do they expect their citizens to mark their property. Real cities do have sidewalks though, and real cities blow the piled up snow in to dump trucks and cart it away. Real cities do not let the giant snow blower throw the dirt, salt, sand and garbage at peoples houses or on the citizens lawns or tear chunks out of their property with plows.

  • Username
    ABBY
    - March 13, 2013 at 11:56:42

    Good luck mr. Porter.Those plow drivers are the "terror of the cabbage patch". They have full reign when it comes to peoples property. We've seen it all before.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    wtf
    - March 13, 2013 at 09:23:53

    The picture shows the problem. There's no sidewalk or anything else to act as a buffer between the street and the lawn. I believe that so much of the land (I don't know how much) from the street center line belongs to the city. It could mean that some or all of that damaged lawn is city property. It's not just street corners that get scalped but any turns in the road as well. The plow operators seem to judge the width of the road by where cars are parked in driveways. They use to scalp our lawn every year until my neighbor and I parked our vehicles out onto the sidewalk (may sound crazy but that what frustration will the city will do). Also, I placed markers along the edge of the lawn. It seems to be working at least there's been no damage s for the last seven years or more. By the way, don't let the city fix your lawn. All they do is throw a roll of sod on the ground. They don't level it or cut it to shape the damage area.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Devil's Advocate
    - March 13, 2013 at 09:08:04

    I feel your pain Mr. Porter. The snow clearing practices of the city are nothing short of disrespectful at best, dangerous and reckless on average. The city does not deserve the title of "city" since services are not comparable to a real city.

    Submit a comment

Submit a comment

Submit a comment (we keep all emails private)
Agreement

We ask that users remain courteous. You may not post insulting, discriminatory or inappropriate content, which may be removed at our discretion. We are not responsible for user content and opinions. Use of this site as well as content submission & ownership are governed by our Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy.

Member organizations should be non-profit in nature, and promote legal activities. Any organization found promoting illegal activities or commercial products or services will be deleted from the site.

I agree with these conditions.

Advertising

Business Directory

Milestones Moving Up

Newsletter

Please enter your email to receive our free newsletter

Subscribe to news alerts

Advertising