• Print
  • Send to a friend
  • Comment (11)
  •  

School bus policy needs fixing

Published on September 20, 2012
Published on September 19, 2012
Topics :
Dear Editor , Farm Road , Meadows

Dear Editor: I am writing regarding what I consider to be a serious situation involving the transportation of students from the area known as Farm Road in Gillams to their school in Meadows.

The present policy only allows for students to be picked up at the former Templeton Collegiate parking lot. The bus does not go all the way in Farm Road.

About 22 students have to walk to catch the school bus in all kinds of inclement weather. These students range in age from five years old to students in senior high.

The parents/caregivers who have to drive their children to the bus stop due to the vast distance are stuck in an uncompromising situation that leaves two choices:

— Do I let my child walk to the bus stop unsupervised to put them at multiple risks? (Which I feel is not an option.)

— Do I quit my job and try to survive by budgeting on one income? (This is something no one should have to do because of a five-minute bus ride)

There are likely several excuses that will be made by the school board as to why this has been allowed to continue for years — such as the road is not plowed well in the winter. To this I ask, why isn’t the road plowed to a suitable standard?

The contractors who receive the money under their tendered contract have a responsibility to fulfill their contract or lose it. Is this not so? Or does our government not abide by the tendering act?

Another excuse could be that the bus does not have enough room to turn around.

According to the School Act, school boards have the responsibility to determine the bus routes based on the number of children using the service, and if it is a low number or the terrain/road conditions are an issue then the school board not only has the right, but it has the responsibility to provide buses which suit the need of the students involved.

I quote here from the 2004 Auditor’s report under the heading Route Planning: “In order to identify the appropriate number and types of vehicles required for student transportation, it is necessary for the boards to know the number and ages of students which require busing. Based upon this information, route planning can then occur. Route planning involves taking the information available on students requiring transportation and then creating and scheduling bus routes and stops for each school year to accommodate these students. Part of a successful route-planning process would involve a regular and consistent monitoring and evaluation process. It is important to know the numbers of students travelling on buses to avoid overcrowding on one hand as well as ensuring that the system remains efficient.”

Reading from the above, it is evident to me that the auditor general felt school boards and the government have a responsibility to ensure the safe transportation of our youth to their school and the safe return to their homes.

We certainly pay enough taxes for road upkeep and for proper transportation of our children. If the roads are a problem, fix the roads. If full-sized buses don’t have the room to turn around, you purchase a smaller bus to suit the need. This is just common sense.

With a copy of this letter, I am advising MHA Eddie Joyce of the situation and I implore for him to intercede on behalf of his constituents and his future voters.

During the school year we have no peace of mind over the safety of our children or sacrificing our livelihood to have peace of mind.

Maria Walsh, Gillams

Comments

  • Username
    Maria
    - September 22, 2012 at 21:20:32

    Thanks everyone for your support. Christa hope your doing well. I know it has been the same for many years, this does not mean it should be that way. You are right it is an issue for many people in many areas and I would support them in there efforts to have their concerns heard. Just hoping that something can be done to help. We have been told each year that the following year the roads will be improved and they would see about the buses coming in, but that year or improvements to the roads have not happened. Mr Joyce is supporting us and is in agreement in this matter and wanted us (the parents) to go public and make noise. I am greatful for his help and support. I am in no way blaming him for this issue, just hoping to shed light on an subject the needs to be illuminated. I can not be blamed for comments that evolve, only my own. I don't think it is correct for me to complain about something that I am not willing to try to improve. Smaller bi-roads with worse conditions, with less children have been given busing in recent years. We are hoping for the same Thanks to everyone for their support.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Tara Wight
    - September 21, 2012 at 14:11:48

    I agree 100%...i too was a student on Farm Road!! They have been talking about the bus going in Farm Road for years! I attended both Templeton Collegiate and Templeton Academy. It is something that should be done! I also lived on Farm Road for a long time and as for the roads in the winter time they are completely ridiculous!! I had to call the counsel last year wondering where the plow truck was too..it was close to supper time before the roads were touched! Why do these people feel a need that bi-roads aren't as important as the main road? These people are being paid to do the roads so do them right! It shouldn't be a cows path all the time and Farm Road has been like it for years!

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    J. Flynn
    - September 21, 2012 at 12:20:48

    Christa From reading the article, I dont think that the author blamed Mr. Joyce, she is asking for his help, which is what he gets paid for isn't it? Maybe you could read it again.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Christa
    - September 21, 2012 at 10:34:23

    While I sympathize with you Maria, there are several more examples of this this type of situation on the North and South Shores of the Bay of Islands. You happen to live on a by-road, and you live there by your own choice. If the school board changes their policy for Farm Road-Gillams, they will then have to change it for the numerous other by-roads. P.S. Not everything is Eddie Joyce's fault

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Lowell Morgan
    - September 20, 2012 at 19:12:23

    Where are you Eddie Joyce? Are you listening to these comments? We want action.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Kayla Porter Cox
    - September 20, 2012 at 19:11:46

    I agree 1000% I was a student on farm road , yes I didn't have to walk very far But the roads where hardly plowed right...I don't think that the plow driving in the middle of the road was good enough...At this time all the buses traveled this road because the school was still open. We would have to walk in the middle of the road so we wouldn't go to our nee's in snow, Now that the school is closed there at day's on end where the road isn't done at all..I can remember the buses almost touching the arm of our jacket...I think it is time for the bus route to be changed to fit the needs of the people living so far in, get one of the smaller buses for them, hope something is done for the safety of the kids.....

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Tom Park
    - September 20, 2012 at 19:10:10

    We have been neglected on the north shore for years. Time to step up. Get this taken care of. (Now)

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Elsie Brake
    - September 20, 2012 at 19:06:59

    Mr Walsh, I could not agree more with your comment. Now lets see what this School Board is made of.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Sue Brenecki
    - September 20, 2012 at 19:02:44

    Has the school board even gotten out to see what this road is like? The School Board is there for the children. Now go see what these families are concerned about. This is very serious. Bad waether is just around the corner and these families should of been taken care of before school started this fall. Now in hind sight lets do right by our children. Walk that road in winter and see how safe it is. Go on and do the proper thing. Make it safe!!!! I dare you.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Garry Walsh
    - September 20, 2012 at 18:01:37

    With regards to this article, I couldnt agree more. This road has been a problem for years both in upkeep and maintenance. The problem with the buses is a no brainer, it is the sole responsibility of the school board to provide an effective and safe mode of transportation.Now to Mr. Joyce, he sat on a committee today in St. John's questioning the Western School board on the way they were spending our tax dollars, my question is " did you bring up this issue? " If not why not? Have you taken any action to resolve this problem? Is the school board spending our tax dollars effectively? Are you looking at their roles, are they fullfilling their mandate? What is your plan with regard to this issue? Not everything in this province is Muskrat Falls. Please respond to this article and let your voters know what your solution is. garryawalsh@hotmail.com

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    cal brake
    - September 20, 2012 at 16:41:30

    very well said

    Submit a comment

Submit a comment

Submit a comment (we keep all emails private)
Agreement

We ask that users remain courteous. You may not post insulting, discriminatory or inappropriate content, which may be removed at our discretion. We are not responsible for user content and opinions. Use of this site as well as content submission & ownership are governed by our Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy.

Member organizations should be non-profit in nature, and promote legal activities. Any organization found promoting illegal activities or commercial products or services will be deleted from the site.

I agree with these conditions.

Advertising

Business Directory


Milestones Moving Up

Newsletter

Please enter your email to receive our free newsletter

Subscribe to news alerts

Advertising